We Keep Giving Them a Pass, and They Keep Proving We’re Fools
In “Our Under-Incarceration Problem, Portland Edition,” Paul Mirengoff shows graphically the savage costs of the nostrum that passes for High Wisdom among criminal justice reformers, to wit, that “everyone deserves a second chance.” Of course many, possibly most, criminals deserve a second chance, but as long as we refuse to ask, “Who specifically are we dealing with?” and “Second chance to do what?” we are thoughtlessly opening the door to more criminal brutality. And we’ll get what you usually get when you open that door — as a Portland, Oregon driver learned last week.